Kevin’s Picks: Open Shell (Replacement Start Menu)

What is Open Shell?

Open Shell is a free, open-source program that replaces the Start Menu. It brings back the classic Start Menu style many of us grew to love over the years, especially if, like me, you long for the simplicity and familiarity of Windows 7. When Classic Shell was discontinued, Open Shell stepped up, and since then, it's gained a loyal following.

With Open Shell, I can customize my Start Menu in countless ways, which gives me a sense of control over how my Windows experience looks and feels.

The Advantages

1. Familiar Interface

Let’s be honest—the Windows 10 and 11 Start Menus aren't for everyone. They’re packed with tiles, shortcuts, and features I rarely use. Open Shell offers a clean, familiar interface that mimics the classic Start Menu of Windows 7, so I can quickly access my apps and settings without all the extra clutter.

2. Customization Galore

As someone who loves tinkering with my setup, Open Shell is a dream come true. I can change the Start Menu’s layout, skin, and behavior to fit my preferences. I can make it minimalist or add more details as I like. Want to change the Start button's appearance? Open Shell lets me do that, too.

3. Improved Search

One of the most frustrating parts of the newer Windows Start Menus is the search functionality—it can be sluggish or inaccurate. Open Shell integrates its search feature, often delivering faster and more reliable results. Whether I’m looking for a specific document, app, or setting, Open Shell helps me find it in seconds.

4. Lightweight and Non-Intrusive

Unlike some third-party programs that can hog resources, Open Shell is lightweight. It doesn’t slow down my computer or interfere with my daily tasks. Plus, if I ever decide it’s not for me, it’s easy to uninstall without leaving a trace.

5. No Learning Curve

Because Open Shell closely resembles older versions of the Start Menu, there’s no steep learning curve. If you’ve used Windows in the past, you’ll feel right at home, just like I did.

The Disadvantages

1. Limited Modern Features

While I love the simplicity of Open Shell, it has some limitations: I don’t get access to some of the modern features built into the Windows 10 or 11 Start Menus.

For example, live tiles, which show real-time information like weather updates or news headlines, aren’t available. So, if you enjoy those interactive elements, Open Shell might feel like a step backward.

2. Occasional Compatibility Issues

Even though Open Shell is regularly updated, there are moments when it doesn’t play nicely with a new Windows update. It’s not common, but on rare occasions, I’ve experienced minor glitches after a major Windows release. However, the development community usually fixes these quickly.

3. Aesthetic Gap

Open Shell might feel outdated if you prefer sleek, modern designs. While it can mimic older Windows versions, it doesn’t offer the same modern flair as Windows 11’s fluid, glass-like interface. The classic look is functional, but it may not appeal to everyone’s aesthetic taste.

4. Dependence on Community Support

Since Open Shell is an open-source project, it relies heavily on community support and contributions. This means updates and bug fixes may not come as frequently or promptly as they might from a large corporation like Microsoft. However, the project has a passionate community, so I rarely feel left in the dark.

Who Should Consider Open Shell?

If you’re like me and nostalgic for the simplicity of older Windows interfaces or just tired of the clutter that comes with modern Start Menus, Open Shell might be exactly what you need. It’s ideal if you value speed, customization, and a no-fuss approach to accessing your apps and settings.

On the other hand, if you’ve embraced the modern features of Windows 10 and 11—like live tiles or the sleek design—you might find Open Shell a bit too retro.

But for those of us who want our computer to work the way it used to, Open Shell is like a breath of fresh, familiar air.

In short, Open Shell is a powerful tool that restores control and familiarity. It may not be for everyone, but for those who miss the “good old days” of Windows, it’s a game-changer.